When we buy a new car, we expect it to be a reliable means of transportation and to meet our needs. Sometimes, however, despite our best intentions and efforts, we end up owning a “lemon,” a car that is repeatedly found to have serious defects. 

In such cases, the Utah Lemon Law comes to the rescue. The Lemon Law is designed to protect consumers from defective cars and provide them with legal protection.

What qualifies for a Lemon law in Utah?

In order to qualify for the Utah Lemon Law, certain criteria must be met. The law states that the manufacturer or distributor must make a reasonable number of attempts to correct the defect. If, after a reasonable number of attempts, the vehicle is still defective, the consumer can claim compensation or replacement.

Here are the main factors that determine whether a car can be considered a lemon under the Utah Lemon Law:

  • Fresh Vehicle Requirement: Utah’s lemon law specifically applies to newly acquired cars through purchase or lease transactions. It does not extend its coverage to used vehicles or those obtained for business purposes;
  • Exclusive Personal Use: The vehicle must be primarily intended for personal, family, or household utilization in order to be eligible. Vehicles primarily employed for commercial purposes are not encompassed by the law’s provisions;
  • Material Defect Criterion: To qualify, the vehicle must exhibit a significant defect or condition that substantially impairs its functionality, value, or safety. This defect must hinder the vehicle’s ability to perform as originally intended;
  • Designated Lemon Law Period: Defects must be reported within the defined Lemon Law Period, which commences either one year from the vehicle’s delivery date or upon reaching the first 12,000 miles of operation, whichever milestone is reached first;
  • Repair Attempts Obligation: The manufacturer or authorized dealer is obligated to undertake a reasonable number of repair attempts to rectify the identified problems. The law mandates that manufacturers be given a fair opportunity to address the defects;
  • Criteria for a Reasonable Number of Repair Attempts: If the vehicle remains defective despite a reasonable number of repair attempts, it may be classified as a “lemon.” The specific threshold for what constitutes a reasonable number can vary but typically involves three or more attempts to fix the same defect or a cumulative total of 30 or more days when the vehicle is out of service due to various defects;
  • Manufacturer’s Notice Requirement: To initiate lemon law proceedings, the consumer must provide written notice to the manufacturer or authorized dealer detailing the identified defects and allow them a final opportunity to rectify the issues before pursuing further action.

If the vehicle meets these requirements, the consumer may be entitled to compensation or a replacement vehicle under the Utah Lemon Law.

Remedies under the Lemon Law

If the vehicle qualifies as a lemon, the consumer may have the following options:

Refund: The consumer may be entitled to a refund of the full purchase price, including taxes, registration fees and finance charges, less reasonable compensation for use of the vehicle.

Replacement: Alternatively, the consumer may request that the vehicle be replaced with a similar vehicle.

books and notebook on the table

Is there a Lemon law for used cars in Utah?

No, Utah’s Lemon Law does not apply to used cars. It is important to note that lemon laws in most states, including Utah, primarily apply to new cars. Used cars are usually sold “as is” without the same protections as new cars. However, this does not mean that consumers who purchase used cars have no recourse if they encounter significant problems with the vehicle.

Instead of relying on Lemon Law protections, consumers buying used cars in Utah should exercise caution and take steps to protect themselves before making a purchase. Here are some tips to consider:

  1. Research the vehicle: Get a vehicle history report to check for reports of accidents, flood damage or previous mechanical problems. It’s also a good idea to research the make, model and year of the car to identify any common problems or recalls;
  2. Independent inspection: Before you finalize your purchase, have a trusted mechanic perform a thorough inspection of your used car. They can identify any existing or potential problems that may not be immediately obvious;
  3. Warranty: Ask about the manufacturer’s remaining warranty or consider buying a certified pre-owned vehicle that may offer additional warranty coverage;
  4. Buy from reputable sellers: Buy from reputable dealers or individuals with a good track record. Be careful when dealing with private sellers and ask a legal professional to check the contract of sale;
  5. Written Agreement: Get a written agreement that describes the condition of the car, any promises made by the seller, and any warranties offered;
  6. Utah Consumer Sales Practices Act: Utah has consumer protection laws such as the Utah Consumer Sales Practices Act, which prohibits deceptive trade practices. If a seller engages in unfair or deceptive practices, consumers can take legal action under this law.

How long is the Lemon law good for in Utah?

In the state of Utah, there exists a protective measure called the Lemon Law, which extends its coverage for a specific duration known as the “Lemon Law Period.” This time frame is precisely defined as either one year from the vehicle’s delivery to the consumer or the first 12,000 miles driven, whichever event occurs earlier.

During this legally stipulated Lemon Law Rights Period, if a newly purchased vehicle is discovered to possess significant defects that substantially impair its use, value, or safety, it is imperative for the consumer to promptly notify the manufacturer or authorized dealer regarding the identified issues. Consequently, the manufacturer or authorized dealer must be provided with a fair opportunity to rectify the problems through a reasonable number of repair attempts.

It is crucial to understand that the Lemon Law rights period does not provide an indefinite shield throughout the entire lifespan of the vehicle. Beyond this specified duration, consumers may no longer be entitled to the protections afforded by the Lemon Law. Therefore, it becomes paramount for consumers to be proactive and promptly identify and report any defects within the designated time frame.

In cases where persistent defects continue to affect the vehicle even after a reasonable number of repair attempts during the Lemon Law period, consumers may have grounds to seek remedies such as a refund or a vehicle replacement.

It is important to emphasize that the precise details and provisions of the Lemon Law may differ, and it is highly recommended to carefully examine the actual Lemon Law provisions in Utah or consult with legal professionals to gain a comprehensive understanding of the specific requirements, rights, and limitations imposed by the law.


Utah’s Lemon Law provides significant protections for consumers who unknowingly purchase defective vehicles. By familiarizing yourself with this law, you will be able to assert your rights and pursue appropriate remedies if you find yourself owning a “lemon.” 

Remember to document all repairs, keep copies of correspondence with the manufacturer or dealer, and consult with an experienced attorney if necessary. 

The Lemon Law serves as a safety net, ensuring consumers get the quality and value they deserve when buying a new car. Be informed, exercise your rights, and don’t let a “lemon” ruin your driving experience.